Last Updated: 10/23/2026
Rankings as of 10/23/2026
Ranked by Highest Rating
- #1 Zombie Hollow — 4.79 (69 ratings)
- #2 Carlisle Haunted Woods — 4.70 (95 ratings)
- #3 Future Nightmares — 4.70 (13 ratings)
- #4 Slaughterhouse — 4.65 (1,739 ratings)
- #5 The Docks — 4.57 (94 ratings)
- #6 Linn’s Haunted House — 4.38 (96 ratings)
- #7 Sleepy Hollow Sports Park — 3.52 (183 ratings)
Ranked by Most Reviewed
- #1 Slaughterhouse — 1,739 ratings
- #2 Sleepy Hollow Sports Park — 183 ratings
- #3 Linn’s Haunted House — 96 ratings
- #4 Carlisle Haunted Woods — 95 ratings
- #5 The Docks — 94 ratings
- #6 Zombie Hollow — 69 ratings
- #7 Future Nightmares — 13 ratings
Combined rating: each site’s score is converted to a 5-star scale (percentages ÷ 20) and weighted by how many ratings it has.
Haunt operators – make sure you have (and control) your entry on these sites. Each is a very important way people will find your business. Some haunts are missing entries, and some have pages that exist but they are not “claimed” meaning anyone could steal that page and control it. Let me know if I can assist! Happy to help, when I can.
- Facebook – shows up in search results.
- Google – used by Android Maps.
- Yelp – used by Apple Maps (iPhone, iPad, Mac, etc.).
- Apple – used by Apple Maps (when no Yelp entry?)
Carlisle Haunted Woods
- Review on Facebook (no rating shown)
- Review on Google (4.7 / 95 reviews)
- Review on Yelp (no reviews) – unclaimed
- Rate on Apple – not listed in Apple Maps
The Docks
- Review on Facebook (96% recommend / 21 reviews)
- Review on Google (4.5 / 72 reviews)
- Review on Yelp – not listed on Yelp
- Review on Apple (100%, 1 rating)
Future Nightmares (show)
- Review on Facebook (Not yet rated, 3 reviews)
- Review on Google (4.7 / 13 reviews)
- Review on Yelp – not listed on Yelp
- Rate on Apple – not listed in Apple Maps
Linn’s Haunted House
- Review on Facebook (92% recommend / 54 reviews)
- Review on Google (4.1 / 41 reviews)
- Review on Yelp (4.0 / 1 review) – unclaimed
- Rate on Apple (0%, No ratings)
Slaughterhouse
- Review on Facebook (94% recommend / 989 reviews) – they lost 10 reviews???
- Review on Google (4.6 / 723 reviews)
- Review on Yelp (4.0 / 12 reviews)
- Rate on Apple (87%, 15 ratings)
Sleepy Hollow Sports Park
- Review on Facebook (Old review page deleted. Was: 78% recommend / 727 reviews)
- Review on Google (3.6 / 165 reviews)
- Review on Yelp (no reviews) – unclaimed
- Rate on Apple – shows the Yelp rating for the Sports Park (2.8 / 18 reviews)
Zombie Hollow (Winterset)
- Review on Facebook (94% recommend / 31 reviews)
- Review on Google (5.0 / 34 reviews)
- Review on Yelp – not listed on Yelp
- Rate on Apple (75% / 4 ratings)
Review Rating Changes
10/23/2026 (since the 10/15/2026 update)
- The Docks: Facebook 96% recommend / 22 → 21 reviews; Google 4.5 / 70 → 72 reviews; Apple unchanged (100%, 1 rating — the listing is under the former Barnum name).
- Future Nightmares: Facebook now shows “Not yet rated” (3 reviews; was 100% recommend), and their Facebook page was renamed “Future Nightmares (Sinn X)”. Google unchanged (4.7 / 13).
- Carlisle Haunted Woods: Google 4.6 / 85 → 4.7 / 94 reviews. Their Facebook page still shows no rating.
- Linn’s Haunted House: Google 4.1 / 40 → 41 reviews. Facebook unchanged (92% recommend / 54 reviews).
- Slaughterhouse: Google 4.6 / 716 → 723 reviews. Facebook unchanged (94% recommend / 989 reviews); Apple unchanged (87%, 15 ratings).
- Sleepy Hollow Sports Park: Facebook review page confirmed deleted (was 78% recommend / 727 reviews). Google 3.6 / 164 → 165 reviews. Apple now shows the scream park’s Yelp rating: 2.5 / 17 → 2.8 / 18 reviews.
- Zombie Hollow: Facebook 94% recommend / 30 → 31 reviews; Google 5.0 / 32 → 34 reviews. Apple unchanged (75%, 4 ratings).
- Yelp (checked by Allen, since Yelp blocked automated access): Linn’s confirmed at 4.0 / 1 review and Slaughterhouse at 4.0 / 12 reviews — both unchanged. Haunted Woods has a Yelp page with no reviews. The Docks, Future Nightmares and Zombie Hollow are not listed on Yelp. Sleepy Hollow’s Yelp page is unclaimed.